Tags: Benjamin Gillies, Municipal Affairs

Downtown Montreal’s waste disposal system sucks

© Troy Media. Please contact the publisher to inquire about publication rates for this column. Our rates are based on circulation. Scroll to the bottom to purchase this column. To view our rates, click here.

October 22, 2012

WINNIPEG, MB, Oct. 22,2012/ Troy Media/ – Since the dawn of prehistory, humans have been creating garbage. It was not until the Middle Ages, however, that the position of paid garbage collector was first established in Britain. Called ‘rakers’, these men were employed to rake up the trash in the street on a weekly basis.

In 1875, England’s Public Health Act gave municipal authority for waste collection, and the concept of a movable garbage receptacle was created. To stem the spread of disease, by the early 20th century governments on both sides of the Atlantic began to implement public waste pickup, which has grown increasingly important over the last century thanks to consumerism and a disposable culture.

Today, cities employ an elaborate network of collection and disposal facilities to deal with the 30 million tonnes of garbage generated each year in Canada. Unfortunately, these systems are not without their problems. Large bins outside apartment complexes or office towers often smell and overflow, for example, while the fleet of garbage trucks and personnel cost millions of dollars per year – and contribute to traffic congestion and carbon pollution.

Despite these flaws, this conventional method of gathering refuse is the norm across Canada. But in downtown Montreal, the foundation is being laid for a totally new way of collecting garbage.

And it’s going to suck.

Beneath rue Ste. Catherine, 1,500 kilometres of pipes will make up the largest vacuum waste removal system in the country. Citizens will put their trash or recyclables into receptacles placed around the neighbourhood, a trapdoor will open, and within seconds the refuse will be flying along at 80 kilometres an hour underneath the street to the recycling centre or other waste management facility.

The system, which will eventually whisk away the garbage generated by 2,350 residences, a number of restaurants, and passersby taking in the various events and festivals happening in the downtown, is designed by Envac, a Swedish firm that has been sucking up garbage for half a century. The company has installed its products in over 600 cities around the world, including Roosevelt Island, New York, back in the 1970s, where to this day it continues to serve the neighbourhood’s 14,000 residents

Proponents argue suction waste facilities are superior to the traditional ‘chuck and truck’ method in just about every area that matters. With trash collection automated and happening underground, garbage trucks can be taken off the streets, reducing traffic congestion and noise. Moreover, though the Envac systems do require electricity, energy use is lower than if a fleet of fuel-powered trucks were sent out. Smelly, overflowing bins are also a thing of the past, even during the holiday season or inclement weather. (When New York City shut down during the snowstorm of 2010, Roosevelt Island was the only area to enjoy uninterrupted garbage service.)

Perhaps most enticing of all, while initial outlay is obviously more expensive than for traditional waste collection, the running and maintenance costs are considerably lower, saving municipalities money overall.

Certainly, such a system would likely not be well-received everywhere, as most private homeowners would probably not appreciate having to walk their garbage to the end of the block to toss it down the chute. In apartment or condo complexes, however, as well as in public spaces like downtowns, or even in smaller spaces like an office park, shopping mall, or hospital (eliminating the need for environmentally-unfriendly plastic garbage bags in these buildings), vacuum waste disposal could be both appropriate and advantageous.

Despite having only eight per cent of the world’s population, it is estimated North Americans are responsible for generating as much as 50 per cent of the planet’s waste, meaning both Canadians and Americans should look seriously at cutting back on how much trash they create.

Nevertheless, as there will always be a need for waste disposal, it should be done as efficiently as possible. While the traditional garbage truck will likely continue to dominate, it is time to consider whether vacuum refuse management also has a role to play in the 21st century city – either as part of new developments or retrofitted during the renovation of existing areas. Because as numerous surveys have shown residents living in Envac system areas are more satisfied with their waste collection than those with conventional collection procedures, there is good reason to believe Montreal is not the only city in Canada that could benefit from a disposal system that, truly, sucks.

Troy Media Municipal Affairs columnist Benjamin Gillies is a political economy graduate from the University of Manitoba, where he focused on urban development and energy policy. He works as a consultant in Winnipeg.

Read more Benjamin Gillies

Follow Benjamin via RSS

Purchase this column. Your cost is based on circulation of your print product. Internet sites enjoy a flat rate. Choose your circulation.

Editor's suggestions

How Transition is starting to rebuild Ontario

This column is FREE to use on your websites or in your publications. However, Troy Media, with a link to its web site, MUST be credited. October 15, 2012 TORONTO, ON, ...